On a spectrum of Real Housewives to Big Brother and maybe even Survivor, The Traitors is somewhere above them all. If there’s one thing the show has proven, it’s that tense and treacherous TV is what really gets people talking. The Traitors franchise, encompassing the UK, US, and Canadian editions, has become a hot topic on social media; it’s like Squid Game‘s response all over again. People aren’t just consuming it, they’re crafting their own strategies, pointing accusatory fingers, and even clocking some intense memes.
The show follows a seemingly simple format: a group of strangers is bunkered together, with some of them secretly designated as Traitors and the rest as Faithfuls. Every night, the group votes a suspected traitor out, and the traitors “murder” one of the faithfuls. The result is a high-stakes, suspicious game that forces players to build uneasy alliances, lie through their teeth, and betray trust as if there were a truckload of money on the line… because there is.
‘The Traitors’ Audience Are Active Participants, and That’s the Magic
You walk into The Traitors thinking, “they can’t possibly tell us who the traitor is from the get-go,” and then they do. This completely changes the way the show is viewed. Now, viewers are not trying to figure out who the traitor is; perhaps that would be easier. It’s an increasingly painful process to watch the contestants circle each other like buzzards and fail so monumentally.
It’s safe to say that this dynamic turns every conversation into something viewers can evaluate in real time. When Season 2’s Dan Gheesling was on, he used a typical under-the-radar strategy, including acts like avoiding direct accusations and speaking in careful circles. When pushed into a corner, he tried to turn on fellow traitor, Phaedra Parks, but that was too little too late.
However, this same strategy worked perfectly for Season 1 contestant Cirie Fields, who stayed under the radar, built strong alliances, and blended into the background throughout her season. When fellow traitor Cody Calafiore was about to tank their entire operation, Fields, alongside fellow traitor Christian de la Torre, voted him out without breaking a sweat.
Watching them scheme and push pieces into place is interesting, but it’s also painful because you see the toll it eventually takes on them. Cerie even cries after they send Shelbe Rodriguez home, admitting that the game is taking its toll. It’s both touching and alarming because, at some point, you forget that these traitors are actual human beings with feelings and not the ruthless plotters the game sets them up to be. In real time, we watch this group of people whittle down to a select few, and by then, you’re invested. It’s hard not to take it personally when yet another faithful is righteously booted or to wince when your favorite traitor is discovered.
RELATED: The Surprising Reality TV Show Cillian Murphy “Can Watch for Hours”
Casting From Different Reality TV Worlds Creates Unscripted Power Clashes
One of the smartest things The Traitors does is force people who learned completely different game languages to sit and plot at the same table. Players like Fields came in with years of experience from Survivor, where she lost and lost… and lost again. What’s the point? She had tons of experience studying people and had been down enough times to avoid rock bottom. So, on The Traitors, she mirrored emotions, planted ideas without taking ownership, and watched her puppets dance.
Then you have players like Season 2’s Peter Weber, whose background on The Bachelor trained him to value reassurance and group harmony. He often tried to resolve tension directly, which works in dating shows but exposes you in a game built on lying. On the other side are civilians like Andie Thurmond, who reacted without the protective habits reality veterans develop. Andie trusted relationships more naturally, which made betrayals more devastating and decisions more emotional.
On the other side of the reality TV veterans are contestants who do not come from long histories of competitive shows, and that contrast is one of the most interesting dynamics. In Season 4, you have people like Olympic figure skaters Tara Lipinski and Johnny Weir or singer and TV personality Eric Nam, both of whom come from worlds far outside the standard reality competition playbook.
They did not learn the ins and outs of making alliances on camera or managing public perception to survive elimination. Sure, they know how to perform under pressure, but in a whole other environment that doesn’t quite feed into the area of social deduction. It’s this sort of mixed dynamic that clicks from the get-go, because watching these instincts collide is golden.
If you’re ready for treachery on a whole other level, stream The Traitors on Peacock.
