Let’s get one thing straight: Comedy Central didn’t cancel Alternatino with Arturo Castro because the storyline went stale. If anything, things were just getting interesting. In its short time, the show managed to deliver more useful commentary than most sketch comedies ever do. Across just 10 episodes, creator/main character Arturo Castro crafted a sketch world that took a closer look at everything from deportation fears to fetishized dating to even disaster tourism. The best part? Every single joke stuck the landing.
Alternatino’s special sauce wasn’t just the ability to play more than 40 distinct characters. He took things up a notch by making all of them feel so incredibly familiar that audiences could find them in their day-to-day. There’s the non-committal guy who manages to luck his way through a stable relationship, a Latino guy on a date realizing he’s being cast as someone else’s fantasy, let’s not forget the post-hurricane skit that takes a real-life political moment and cranks the absurdity way up. While there were always laughs, it was the recognition of these over-the-top characters and situations that really hit home. In all, the show had this uncanny ability to understand range, so one minute Castro could be painfully oblivious and the next outrightly silly. Admirably, that versatility came from his personal experiences of being typecast, underestimated, or asked to play “foreign” without substance. In the year since, that hilarious sincerity hasn’t aged badly at all.
‘Alternatino with Arturo Castro’ Knew Exactly Who It Was Mocking and Trusted You to Get It
Hands down, one of the main reasons Alternatino resonated with audiences is that it never talked down to them. There was this silent understanding that viewers would clock each reference, most likely become mildly uncomfortable, and still find it hilarious. It’s that level of confidence that sells the brief to the tee. In one sketch, Castro dons whiteface to play an ICE agent pitching “cage-free” spaces for detained migrant children inaome messed-up semblance of a PR campaign. The thing is, the whole situation isn’t trying to slap lipstick on a pig; it’s ugly on purpose because the policy wasn’t a secret. Then, in another instance, the show splices actual footage of President Donald Trump tossing paper towels in Puerto Rico after Hurricane Maria, then spins it into a full-blown musical fantasy about how one towel magically fixes everything from broken limbs to severed power lines. Yes, it’s over the top, but the joke wouldn’t land any other way.
While there are heavy political and cultural undertones to Alternatino, it doesn’t trap itself in that box by any means. In one popular skit, Castro also plays a painfully noncommittal DJ who drifts into marriage as nonchalantly as he possibly could. There’s also a Christian Grey knock-off that put the “shade” in Fifty Shades and an over-eager dad to be who takes his gender reveal party a bit too seriously. It’s worth noting that none of these sketches lean into Latino culture, but they aren’t particularly out of place. They use on-brand humor to deliver jokes about modern masculinity, performative adulthood, and social cluelessness. This range is another thing that defined the show as fresh and borderline renegade. Viewers never knew whether they were getting a gangster older than the dawn of time or an action star making his own explosion sounds with his mouth.
RELATED: This Short-Lived Comedy-Drama Will Make You Want To Start a New Life
‘Alternatino’ Found the Sweet Spot Between Daring Humor and Smart Satire
Jumping right in, sketch comedy has always been a bit of a bad boy. There’s no actual way to be soft about it, but going too hard often gets labeled as tasteless. With that in mind, it’s safe to say that most shows that died prematurely weren’t cut short because audiences were waiting for the joke to land. In fact, it’s the polar opposite. They went too far and drove right off a cliff.
One of the cleanest cautionary tales would have to be 1969’s Turn-On, a show so vulgar that some stations pulled it off the air mid-episode. It charged headfirst into risque territory, relying on sexual shock for reactions instead of substance. Most viewers probably didn’t know it had a storyline before it was cancelled… the same night it aired. Then there’s Stankervision, a show that owned its offensiveness, and ended the joke once the audience went ‘ew.’ There’s probably not much to be expected from a show with a central character named Yucko… the clown. Despite its unique and interactive premise and stellar ratings, the sponsors reportedly couldn’t get behind the show’s schtick, and so it was off the air after five episodes.
Here’s the thing, Alternatino played in the same risky sandbox, but it knew how to balance things out. The comedy was always at the forefront, whether the issue was immigration or toxic masculinity. As absurd as it sounds, it was natural, and it opted to explore people’s bad choices, their social awkwardness, and even their strengths. Even better, Arturo Castro never placed himself above the joke. From being the US president’s mole sniffing out opportunistic immigrants to the worst interpreter on the face of the earth, he always aimed to be the butt of his own jokes. All in all, he crossed the line just enough to make his point, but covered it with so much humor and absurdity that he instantly became an audience favorite.
Alternatino with Arturo Castro never got a second season, and technically, it was never cancelled. However, Season 2 never happened largely because Quibi, the streaming platform it moved to after Comedy Central, folded. As such, its last episode aired on August 20, 2019.
You can still catch all 10 episodes on Prime Video, and best believe they’re worth every laugh.
